Election Fights in School
Posted by rebecca on October 28, 2008 at 10:00am
photo: Ayesha Walker

Adobe Flash Player is not installed. Please download and install it to listen to audio.

(download mp3)
 
By Erin Bilir

(aired on NPR's Weekend Edition Sunday on November 2, 2008 and Colorado Public Radio on October 31, 2008)

As I walk down the halls of my high school, I catch snippets of conversation. Joe left Anna, Lisa can’t find her math binder, Jessie’s parents just don’t understand her. But then I hear something different: two friends locked in verbal combat over McCain and Obama. At first they’re debating foreign policy, but pretty soon, they’re making vague accusations like, “you only think that because you are one of those.” Both my friends are agitated, sweaty, and have that darting, wild look in their eyes. They appear deeply convinced that the other is dead wrong.

Heated screaming matches and hallway posturing about the election are happening all the time at my tight-knit school. Students wear buttons, hats, and t-shirts, put campaign stickers on lampposts, cafeteria doors, and dark corners of the library, and even string yard signs around their necks.

Believe me, I get why we’re so into this election. It’s one of the most polarizing our country has seen thus far and for good reason. There is a lot at stake—including the economic crisis, which has kids my age seriously stressed out about how we’ll ever pay for college or someday actually land a job. My teacher says maybe there’s an upside to all this opposition. She/he told me the other day that all the political and economic turmoil we’re facing might actually force the two parties to reassess their political values—and that’s a good thing. He/she says maybe it’s an opportunity to revitalize our country.

But I’m not sure about that. If people around my age, many of whom can’t drive without a licensed adult in the car much less vote, are this divided over the election, I worry about the unity of our nation.

When we stake out such strong positions at a young age, we’re not getting a lot of practice coming up with real solutions.

To me, school isn’t really the place for political showdowns, especially when some of the arguments are based off of nothing more than a handful of Saturday Night Live skits. Subjects like gay marriage and abortion seem to bring on the nastiest exchanges. Either you are a “baby-killer” or religious fanatic who condones rape and incest. With many of us so headstrong and brimming with parent-instilled biases, I don’t see a lot of room for open dialogue, let alone revitalization.

So how’d my friends in the hallway resolve their dispute? With false smiles and the pithy “let’s agree to disagree” head wag. This succinct and unfinished end seems to perfectly sum up the nature of the growing partition in my school and in our country; one in which everyone is just arming for the next fight.





Tensions high

During the 2008 election, tensions were high, because we were at such a critical political, social and economic juncture in our nation's history that it affected everyone from industry titans to high schoolers. Great article. Howie Hubler

I can see both sides

I think political discussions in the school setting should be encouraged when held in a classroom and their is a teacher there to moderate the conversation and to make sure everyone is respectful of opinion and point of view. Howie Hubler

let’s agree to disagree”

let’s agree to disagree” seems to come into play. I agree with what you say about the growing partition and that everyone is just arming for the next fight, you couldn't be more correct.

Election Fights in School

I agree with you, school is not the right place for political discussion, especially, when pupils don´t have their own opinion. Ornela from cheap web hosting

totally agree

yes I totally agree with you especially in a midst of confusion. In school,we must shared our own personal statement so as to be stated and well be respected to politics. School are the best rendezvous for a political topic. Right? Dan Mark O.

Elections should be used to

Elections should be used to promote discussion but not fights. bed & breakfast Barcelona

Differing beliefs

Sure the election result will have a huge impact on everyone and feelings will be strong as to which camp you support, but whatever other peoples beliefs and views have to be respected despite the fact that they might not be your own.

I believe the information

I believe the information covered in the discussion is top notch. I've been doing a research on the subject and your blog just cleared up a lot of questions.Google

Good article

It seems that there are so many people who have strong opposite opinions, and "let’s agree to disagree” seems to come into play. I agree with what you say about the growing partition and that everyone is just arming for the next fight, you couldn't be more correct. Buy hoodia | Fast house sale | proactol ingredients

agree

i think every youth deserve a right there.

small business grants

you are right. small business grants

I believe the information

I believe the information covered in the discussion is top notch. I've been doing a research on the subject and your blog just cleared up a lot of questions. I am working on a buy essay and buy research paper for my English class and currently reading lots of blogs to study.college papers | free essay

I know this...

Election Fights in School - nice :) I have fought for my rights in school too some time ago :) -------------------------------------------------- I am an Internet marketer and I work hard on these project right now: grow taller | jump higher | phone | internet hosting

I think so

This is in a major way condusive to my thinking. It's especially true with regard to saving money and promo codes

Election Fights in School

I think everyone is entitled to have an opinion. This is good because you voice needs to be heard. Great read, thank you. san francisco bicycle lawyer

It has been some time since

It has been some time since I have written about education. Call it a combination of burn out on the issue, and an interest in returning to anonymity. Like dozens of parents, I spent hundreds of hours lobbying, fighting and threatening to save our schools, starting with my kid’s school, then spreading to peninsula schools, and then spreading to reforming the school capital planning system. The fight was over three years long. In the end the “Imagine Our Schools” process, put forward in part because of our demands, produced almost no serious change from past plans. Lots of citizen’s energy, lots of hope, vacuumed up into a vortex of ambiguity and paternalistic policies determined from above. ( custom essay , research paper and Criticism Thesis )

Essay on youth radio

Great!! Please check out CNVC. It may iterest you

Post new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.