Why Suicide? [UPDATED]
Posted by wilmer on February 13, 2010 at 10:00am

Adobe Flash Player is not installed. Please download and install it to listen to audio.

(download mp3)
 

As heard on WABE, Atlanta.
Part of this commentary was cut short in the broadcast version. This transcript reflects the full essay.


By Myia Lane-Vickers

Many of my friends have tough lives. Heck, most of them live in single family homes and face struggles every day - but I don’t think they would ever consider ending their lives. Yet, suicide is ranked as the third leading cause of death for American teenagers.

Recently, while listening to the radio in the car on my way to school, I heard on the news that a young lady committed suicide. She was just 17 years old like me. But apparently she was unlike me in one way because I think committing suicide is pathetic. From my perspective, the girl had no vision for the future. I myself am looking forward to many things, like attending college next year – hopefully in California.

The newscaster said the girl who died was a church going girl! As someone who goes to church, I don’t know how that can be. I believe her decision to end her life shows no belief in a higher source, so it’s hard for me to have sympathy for her. Sadly, her parents will never be able to see her accomplish major goals, marry, live happy, settle in a career, and make a difference. She didn’t even graduate high school.

 

I wake up each morning with a positive attitude. I am thankful for my life - it is a gift that I choose to live every day. Even on days that I am sick, fail a test or get yelled at by mother, I know it’s just part of life. If it rains when I am at the beach in Florida, my vacation isn’t ruined.

 

I can’t imagine suicide as a solution for anyone’s problems. I would hope a friend would ask me for help if they were in crisis – I would never want to hear that they ended their life.

 




Yep, it's sad. I don't think

Yep, it's sad. I don't think it's pathetic.

Suicide = pathetic?

Glad your life is so swell cause I have friends who are coping with some pretty tough crap and it's not their fault. Let me ask you this if you were being molested by your dad and felt helpless---what would you do. Suicide may seem like the easy way out, I'm not saying that's what should happen but, don't call people pathetic especially when you don't know what they've been thru.

My Response

If I were in that situation...I would consult to people who could help me. Grant it, this response is typical. All i know is that suicide is not the right way to go.

suicide

Myia---I think you fail to realize that for many people committing suicide is not about feeling pathetic towards life…often it’s the final result of serious mental problems and for teens it’s depression. You should feel blessed not to know what that’s like. Imagine how a parent of a youth dead by suicide feels hearing your youth radio piece and spewing a blanket generalization about a subject you obviously didn’t research before writing. How do you know the young lady didn’t believe in a higher power…understand everyone in your generation doesn’t lead a Disney life. Think of all your counterparts that are bullied and chose suicide as a release. I know of a young man that recently took his life because of an abusive environment. He had a lot of potential but I didn’t know of his situation. He might have been fearful but not pathetic. Shame on you, youth radio and WABE in Atlanta for airing your insensitive remarks. I hope you grow to understand suicide while you’re living it up and pursuing a college education. Brooke (and the many voices that have been silenced by suicide)

Post new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.